I have good news and bad news about Forgetting Sarah Marshall.
Good news first: It's a very well done, fun and enjoyable film, and well worth your time.
The bad news(for those of you expecting another 40 Year Old Virgin or Knocked Up): Forgetting Sarah Marshall is not exactly a comedy.
Like last year's surprise smash hit Juno, Forgetting Sarah Marshall is a more mature and semi-serious film than the trailers make it appear. While there are some extremely well done laugh-out-loud moments and killer lines, FSM is not so much a comedy as it is a character study and parable about accepting the reality of a given situation, then growing up and dealing with it, in order to move on and leave pain and doubt behind.
Peter Bretter(Jason Segel) is a television score composer who writes the music for a cop series, the star of which is his girlfriend, actress Sarah Marshall(Kristen Bell). Peter's a nice enough guy, but he's just that: a typical guy who often lays about the house in sweats doing nothing when he should be working. One day after coming out of the shower(and be forewarned: the movie begins and ends with Segel's nudity; if you're not a fan of gratuitous penis shots, this isn't the flick you want to see. If you are a fan...well, good for you), Sarah surprises Peter by coming home early. She begins to have a talk with him, and Peter instantly intuits that Sarah's breaking up with him. There is absurdity of course, in Sarah conversing with a naked Peter, but it's a real moment(based on an inci-dent which supposedly once happened to Segel) and the dialogue(the script was also written by Segel) helps sell it.
Naturally devastated--one of the more hilarious running gags is that Peter has hysterical crying jags where he sounds just like a woman each time he thinks of the breakup--Peter turns to his half-brother Brian(Saturday Night Live's Bill Hader) and by default of Brian's marriage, his wife Liz(fellow SNL co-conspirator Liz Cackowski). Peter goes through all the stages of a breakup: shock, depression(wherein he tries to bed any woman in range), anger and finally an attempt to accept it and just get away from it all by taking a trip to Hawaii.
Things don't initially go well for Peter when almost immedi-ately upon his arrival, he finds that not only has Sarah also come to Hawaii and is staying in the same hotel--but that she's come with her current lover, British rock star and infamous lothario Aldous Snow(Russell Brand). In spite of this setback, Peter finds the island and its inhabitants welcoming, especially the front desk hostess Rachel(Mila Kunis), who goes above and beyond the standard customer service route in order to put Peter's mind at ease and help him enjoy his stay.
A few things simply must be pointed out, in praise of both the script and the cast. First of all, the story and characters all ring true in very nearly every instance. Not just the pain that comes with a breakup, but also the ways--sometimes foolish, sometimes illogical and most definitely embarrassing--in which both men and women react to such a circumstance. The film very cleverly switches back and forth at certain instances between what is happening in the present time and point-of-view memories for either Peter or Sarah, as they recall the relationship and each begins to realize what they've either lost or gained in their present relationships, and the reality of what their own was truly like...the good and the bad.
Forgetting Sarah Marshall is also a winner in the develop-ment of the title character's new squeeze, Aldous. Naturally when we're first introduced to him, the instinct is to hate him because Peter's the hero of the picture and he's a nice guy. Besides which, Aldous is the kind of woman stealer every guy hates: handsome, rich, and with his pick of women to choose from. He's seemingly got it all...but of course, he has to have
your girl as well. However, as written by Segel(
How I Met Your Mother,
Knocked Up) and ably acted by Brand(
St. Trinian's,
Penelope), we soon come to find out that in spite of his sexual promiscuity, Aldous is a
genuinely nice guy, which always makes for a more interesting character interaction than the standard jackass we're supposed to blow raspberries at from our seats.
While Jason Segel manages to completely sell his charac-ter of Peter and Kristen Bell is solid as the titular character, by far the surprising standout among the cast is the beautiful Mila Kunis(Family Guy, Robot Chicken) as Rachel. Kunis doesn't just shine in the role of a completely believable and complex female character--she radiates sheer brilliance. Finally freed from the stilting shackles of That '70s Show, Kunis has a chance to flex her acting muscles and deliver a performance which is captivating and makes one long for her reappearance every time she exits a scene. In crafting the persona of Rachel, she becomes the embodiment of the dream girl every guy fantasizes about meeting while on holiday.
While the cast is primarily solid throughout, it doesn't mean
Forgetting Sarah Marshall is not without its flaws. For one thing, there is a minor subplot about a newly married couple on honeymoon who are having problems with their sex life. While such plot devices are usually the province of executive produc-er Judd Apatow(
The 40 Year Old Virgin,
Superbad), here it intrudes clumsily upon the central storyline. While it does produce some minor chuckles(the best of which comes in the ultimate resolution with a sexual tutorial by Aldous), for the most part it's an irritant and impediment. There is also an extended cameo by Jonah Hill(
Knocked Up,
Click) as a waiter at the hotel resort. While Apatow should be applauded for wanting to work with a regular stable of actors, here Hill's character provides extremely few laughs and his comic timing is off just a bit, as he seems bewildered and lost in his minor role.
Overall however, the story is strong and almost too clever on some levels than what may be appreciated in order to give the film long legs at the box office. It takes clever shots at the conventions of cop shows like the one in which Sarah stars, first by pairing her with William Baldwin(
Dirty Sexy Money,
Danny Phantom) as her partner and saddling both with inane, cliched dialogue, then an even worse show where she teams with
Juno's Jason Bateman. There is also an
amazingly clever potshot taken at Kristen Bell's 2006 horror snoozefest
Pulse, which possibly only those reading this review will actually get. For me, this was one of the biggest laughs in the film.
Again, Sarah Marshall isn't exactly the type of comedy one might expect. But thanks to Segel's script and a strong direc-torial debut from Nicholas Stoller, a trip to your local cinema to watch this one will be an evening you won't soon forget.
ABSOLUTELY UNFORGETTABLE
New comedy from Apatow and company works because it comes from the heart...
Don't forget: See Sarah Marshall. You'll be a happier camper for it.
Peter(Segel, right) does his best initially to forget Sarah Marshall. The plan doesn't work quite as well as he'd like.
Lovely Mina Kunis plays Rachel, the hostess at Peter's hotel... and quite possibly, the girl he is actually meant to be with.
Brand as Aldous Snow, the woman stealer you want to hate... but just can't.
Forgetting Sarah Marshall: A superb cast carries a well done film ably on their shoulders.